The United States has violated international trade rules by imposing tariffs on Chinese goods in 2018, the WTO dispute settlement panel ruled on the 15th. As soon as the news came out, it immediately attracted the extensive attention of domestic and foreign media.
The ruling pointed out that the United States, based on article 301 of its trade law, imposed tariffs on Chinese goods totalling more than $234 billion in June and September 2018 on the grounds of intellectual property protection, which violated the "most favored nation treatment" and "tariff reduction schedule" provisions of the 1994 GATT.
The U.S. panel believes that there is no sufficient justification for the United States to impose an exception to the public tariff clause to justify its actions. The dispute settlement panel believes that the United States has damaged China's rights and recommended that the United States correct the relevant illegal measures.
What is the response of China and the United States?
A spokesman for the Ministry of Commerce said that China appreciates the objective and impartial ruling made by the panel. It is necessary for China to safeguard its legitimate rights and interests by resorting to the WTO dispute settlement mechanism for the US side's wrong practices of unilateralism and trade protectionism. It also demonstrates China's firm determination to respect WTO rules and safeguard the authority of the multilateral trading system.
A spokesman for the Ministry of commerce also said that the multilateral trading system with the WTO as the core is the cornerstone of international trade. China has always firmly supported and safeguarded this cornerstone and respected WTO rules and rulings. China also hopes that the United States will fully respect the ruling of the expert group and the rule-based multilateral trading system, take practical actions, go against China and other WTO members, jointly safeguard the multilateral trading system and promote the stable and healthy development of the world economy.
The Chinese Embassy in the United States also tweeted: "we hope that the United States will respect the ruling and take practical actions to safeguard the multilateral trading system."
On the same day, US trade representative Robert Lighthizer also issued a statement in response to the ruling. The statement said the ruling once again showed the "lack of capacity" of the WTO, especially in the field of intellectual property disputes. The WTO does not have any remedial measures.
Lethizer also said the ruling will not affect the implementation of the first phase of the Sino US trade agreement. "The first phase of the Sino US trade agreement includes new, enforceable measures to prevent China from stealing American technology."
What is the impact of the subsequent ruling?
According to the process of the WTO dispute settlement mechanism, the United States should comply with the relevant rulings, correct its 301 tariff measures against China as soon as possible, and reduce the tariff implemented under the investigation to the level stipulated in GATT 1994.
The BBC reported that the trump administration, which has always been critical of the WTO, may appeal the ruling, but the appeal may be paralyzed by law after the trump administration blocked the appointment of new judges to the WTO Appellate Body.
According to the Bangkok Post, the trump administration accused the WTO Supreme Court of "too much power" and blocked the appointment of new judges. Since then, the European Union, China and some other countries have started the provisional adjudication mechanism for settling trade disputes, but the United States has not joined in.
Therefore, if the United States appeals further, the case can only be suspended for the time being. In fact, in the previous steel trade dispute with India, the United States took advantage of the fact that the appellate body had been "paralyzed" to escape adverse rulings.
As far as China is concerned, if the United States refuses to change its tariff policy, China will have the right to countervail, but it needs to obtain the arbitration permission of the WTO before countervailing. However, the departure of former director general azevido at the end of last month has also affected the appointment of arbitrators and the granting of arbitration permission.
Nevertheless, the ruling is still of positive significance in clarifying the merits and demerits of China and the United States on the issue of tariff increase.
Some commentators said that for Germany, France, India and many other countries under the "301 investigation" of the United States, the ruling is obviously a major victory.
